A little late to the Rogue One game but, here I am, anyways. This review will have no barriers on spoilers, so, if you haven't seen Rogue One yet, DO NOT READ!!!!
Okay, everyone else still here? Good. Now, I'll go through the things that I loved.
The effects
The special effects were definitely one of the best parts of this movie. They are the realest effects I've seen in any Star Wars film. Yeah, The Force Awakens' effects were done almost the same way, but the effects in TFA looked like "summer blockbuster" effects, where there's just so much effects, all looking clean and crisp, and being color graded to follow a strict color scheme. Rogue One's effects looked so real and physical, like they could actually be in that same space as the characters. It was very gritty, very realistic. 9/10.
The music
It seems like Star Wars fans are split about the music. It seems like either you love it or hate it. John Williams, as you probably well know, did not come back for this film, being replaced by Michael Giacchino. He only had four weeks to write the score, but the music doesn't really show it. The soundtrack is far superior to Williams' TFA score, in my opinion. Here are a few of my favorite pieces:
- Wobani Imperial Labor Camp
- Your Father Would Be Proud
- Hope
- The Imperial Suite
With "The Imperial Suite" being my favorite. It's right up there as one of the best Star Wars songs. 9/10
The political message
This film goes heavy with politics, and, unlike the prequels, it makes it interesting. It's obviously anti-Trump, with the antagonist being a white supremacist, and the main cast mostly consisting of people of color fighting against a totalitarian conservative government. People complain that Disney is going full-on feminist with both TFA and RO having female protagonists, but, the thing is, every other Star Wars movie had a male protagonist, so you must be really sexist if you're triggered about a female main character. Liberals get triggered about male main characters, yes, but it's just that we've seen them in almost every film ever made, and we'd like a little more diversity. 10/10
The humor
This movie is definitely one of the darkest Star Wars movies, but, in contrast, it is also probably the funniest, so it makes you feel a very broad range of emotions instead of just being a depressing war film. K-2SO is downright hilarious and Chirrut Imwe has a few humorous moments as well. A lot of people complain about the humor that Disney is now putting into the Star Wars films, but you guys complained about the lack of humor in the prequels, and Disney is trying not to be the prequels, so here we are. 8/10
Now for the negatives.
Tarkin and Leia
If you think I'm going to get into the ethics about resurrecting dead actors, I'm not. There's plenty of that online already. I think that if the filmmakers have permission from the actor's family, they can do whatever they want. But I'm going to talk about the effects themselves.
GRAND MOFF TARKIN: The motion capture was *good*. I never felt as though he was in the same physical space as the other characters, but there are a few shots that look fairly realistic. YouTube movie critic Chris Stuckmann said that Tarkin was just a little distracting, and I agree. There was never a single shot of Tarkin where I
didn't think about the effects. 4/10
PRINCESS LEIA: Looks completely real and human. The best motion capture I have ever seen. The only problem? It really doesn't look like her. I mean, when they have side-by-side comparisons, it looks exactly like Carrie Fisher, it looks exactly like her, to the detail, but for some reason, it just... doesn't. It's really weird. 7/10
The characters
The thing about the characters is that they all felt far too passive. Yeah, they all die, but there's never really any weight to their deaths. I mean, yeah, they made me feel sad, but not, like, really sad. You never really knew much about them, which, in some cases, are really nice to add some mystery to them and make them interesting, but here, you just get a one sentence backstory for each character. They really don't have any personality, like the ones in TFA did, and nothing was really explored or explained. The acting in this movie is amazing, but the characters themselves didn't really help it. :/ 3/10
The editing
The entire pace of the movie changed so much, especially in the first two acts. Everything felt either extremely rushed, or extremely drawn out. The first act, especially, was really confusing and it kind of felt like we were being dragged around this world and jerked around so much, and you never could really acknowledge much before *GASP* OFF TO A NEW PLANET!!! It tried so hard to have this level of mystery like TFA had that it ended up ruining the movie. 2/10
So, all in all, I'd give it about 7/10. Solid movie.